Wednesday, January 27, 2016

What about the Jews? Season 4, Episode 3

 So, this week in History and Philosophy of Music Education, we explored music and music education in colonial and early America.  Not only did we examine this period of American musical history, we did so through the lens of two American sub-groups often underrepresented in music education curricula: women and African Americans.  As I read the weekly course material, I think I had a different reaction than most might have.  I read at length about issues surrounding the church's place in music education, the music and music education of slaves, and the role of women in music and music education.  I couldn't help but ask, "what about the Jews?"  Amidst the lengthy descriptions of American Christian musical heritage, there was not a single mention of the Jewish experience.

Often, the squeaky wheel gets the oil.  And certain American sub-groups are louder than others in the quest for recognition.  Women and African Americans are two such groups.  But, is it enough to just address those who are making noise?  What about other, quieter groups of people who have rich culture and traditions? I don't want my American experience and the American experience of my culture to be marginalized.  But, how can we possibly do justice to every component of the American "melting pot?"  I can't answer that question yet and I am not sure it has an answer.  What I do have are some interesting tidbits about the early American Jews and their music that I discovered after feeling left out of the materials for my class.  Here is the story of the first American Jews:

While there were Jewish individuals who made their way to America, the first American Jewish community is accepted to have been established in 1654.  There had been a pretty substantial Jewish community in Dutch-controlled Brazil.  When Portugal got Brazil back from the Dutch, the Jews left.  Many of them settled in places around the Caribbean, some went home to Amsterdam, and one boatload of 23 Jews wound up in New Amsterdam (which became New York).  Peter Stuyvesant, the governor of New Amsterdam, did not want Jews in his colony and ordered their deportation.  Unfortunately for him, but fortunately for us, he was under the employ of the Dutch West India Trading Company, which was funded, in part, by wealthy Dutch Jews.  So, the hateful, anti-semetic Governor Stuyvesant














was overruled by his Jewish bosses.















The Dutch West India Company sent 5 affluent Jewish families to help settle the Jews in their new home.  And Jewish immigration to New Amsterdam commenced from Amsterdam and Dutch territories.

What I found interesting is that the first Jewish settlers in America were not Ashkenazi; they were Sephardic.  See, what had happened was Spain did this little thing called the inquisition (what a show!).

To escape the horrors of the Inquisition (or possibly the horrors of being in a Mel Brooks movie), some crypto-Jews (Jews who publicly converted to Catholicism to escape persecution, but privately remained Jewish) fled Spain and settled in North Africa and the Mediterranean.  These Jewish communities came to be known as Sephardic Jews, from the Hebrew word for Spain: s'farad.  Some crypto-Jews elected to remain in Spain and practice Judiasm secretly.  But, as the Dutch were gaining their independence from Spain, crypto-Jews took the opportunity to move to Amsterdam.  You see, the Dutch, being protestant, welcomed the Jews as fellow haters of the Catholic Church and saw them as a beneficial addition to the middle and merchant classes needed to bolster the Dutch capitalist economy.  These Jews came to be known as Western Sephardic Jews and it was members of this community that immigrated to Brazil and finally to New Amsterdam.

The musical traditions of this Jewish community were an oral tradition passed from hazzan (cantor) to hazzan.  Western Sephardim, having been unable to practice Judiasm for so long, had no formal Jewish traditions left when they finally arrived in Amsterdam.  So, they employed Sephardic hazzanim from North Africa and the Mediterranean to come teach them the Sephardic Jewish musical traditions.  The Western Sephardim found this music hard to wrap their minds around.  It had been influenced by the musical traditions of the Islamic lands in which it had been flourishing and was characterized by a nasal timbre, rhythmic improvisation, melodic ornamentation, and non-western tonalities.  So, the Western Sephardim "westernized it, blending it with some of the European musical conventions they had become accustomed to as well as some of the Ashkenazi musical traditions.  It was this "composite" musical tradition that made its way to America.  The colonial American Jews were so concerned with the correctness of their musical tradition that they imported hazzanim from Amsterdam to ensure they did it right.  It is thought that the musical tradition was an incredibly important part of their Jewish identity because of the expense paid to bring in musical experts.

There was a choir in the Western Sephardic tradition.  The choir was a set group of trained singers whose job was to provide a musical example for the congregation and lead them through the sung prayers.  The choir sang in unison and it is unknown how often they were used in synagogue services. 

There are some obvious reasons why the Jewish musical tradition of the American colonies has become lost in the Christian tradition that dominated the American colonies.  First, the Jewish tradition was an oral one whereas the Christian tradition included notation.  Second there, were so few Jews in relation to the number of Christians.  By the American Revolution, there were only 5 cities with established Jewish communities: New York, Newport, Savannah, Charleston, and Philadelphia.  And third, though we are all taught that the Americas were founded as a place for religious freedom, it was really only founded as a place for religious freedom for some, not all.  Though, the Jews were allowed to settle in New Amsterdam, Stuyvesant and later, the British, imposed restrictions on when and how the Jews could observe their religion.  Some of Stuyvesant's decrees were overturned by the Dutch West India Company.  But, it wasn't until 1730 that the first Synagogue in New Amsterdam was allowed to be built.  One of the early synagogues, Mikveh Israel (founded in 1740), still operates today in Philadelphia using the Western Sephardic musical tradition observed in colonial times.  I think I may go check it out!  Does anyone want to come?

If you want to read more about the musical history of Jews in America, I found this great website: http://www.milkenarchive.org/articles/view/introduction-to-volume-1#colonial


Other than that, not a lot of note happened last week.  I still feel like I am struggling through the technology for the online class.  I am not convinced that will change.

Well, folks, they can't all be amazingly interesting weeks.  But, I hope next week will be more exciting for you.  I should be getting back to my scholarly reading, so I will have some fun articles to review for your next week.

Until then, Future Dr. Mitch, out!

Monday, January 18, 2016

Indiana, Season 4, Episode 2.5

Don't freak out.  You didn't miss anything.  The 2.5 above is because Blogger is experiencing technical issues and I had to work around something.  Moving on...

Sometimes, it is nice to dip your toe in the water and ease your way in.

This was not that kind of week.

 You might remember that last semester I was building a digital database using FileMaker Pro for the music education instrument inventory.  The database is meant to move us away from paper records and keep all records electronically.  Well, I designed quite the database.  By the end of the semester, it was operational and I had populated all the instrument information.  All that was missing was a signature pad so loan forms could be signed digitally.  I found a company who makes a FileMaker Pro plugin for signature pads, and we bought the plugin and the pad.  I was super excited when it came in this past week.  I took it to the pet shop, plugged it in, and


it did not work.  I spent hours trying to get it working to no avail.  I ended up calling the company for tech support and the guy I spoke to told me, "hmm... it should work.  I don't know what to tell you.  Call us back if you figure out what is wrong."  So incredibly helpful, thank you, Mr. Man.  I will keep you all updated.

Last semester, Graduate Seminar in Music Education was less than successful.  Thankfully, the faculty heard our feedback and did something about it.  At our first session this past week, the faculty sat us down and asked for our input.  They wanted to know what we hoped to get out of the seminar experience.  I applaud the faculty for realizing they were not meeting our needs and involving us in the process of course correcting (pardon the pun).  Many great ideas were offered by my classmates.  My suggestion came from an idea I had last semester for a seminar project.  I suggested that we put together a graduate student journal.  It would be a scholarly, peer-reviewed journal modeled after the major journals of the field.  I am excited to see what the faculty decides to do with seminar now that they have heard our ideas.

Later in the week, I had a meeting with Dr. C. to discuss my independent study for the semester.  We decided on two projects.  

Project #1
Last fall we hosted a community band symposium.  You might remember my post on the event.  Our undergrads participated in the event.  I thought it was wonderful that our students get the opportunity to be so immersed in the community band world, with events such as this one and Night Owls being hosted at the university.  So, I started to wonder: is there a connection between music majors' attitudes toward the importance of community bands and whether there is a community band at their university.  So, I am going to research this.
Project #2
I started thinking that the graduate student journal that I proposed in seminar might be better served as a separate entity than as part of a course.  So, I proposed that I use my independent study to set it up.  Dr. C. agreed.  She also told me that she was very impressed with this idea.  In her words, "this idea has teeth."  She told me that she is often impressed with how innovative my ideas are.  Hearing that made me feel really positive about my future as a music education professor.  I think it bodes well for me that I am able to keep coming up with ideas that push the boundaries and challenge the accepted conventions of the field.  So, I will be setting up the framework for the journal by answering the essential questions: who, what, where, when, why, and how.  I hope to have everything set up so we can get started in the fall and publish our first issue before winter break.
Dr. C. did make an astute observation during our meeting she said that I have so many ideas and interests that I have the tendency to spread myself thin.  She recommended I take the time to list out everything that I have to do this semester so I can properly allocate my time and design the scope of my projects to fit the time I have.  So, here is my list
  • Classes
    • Wind Symphony
    • Graduate Seminar in Music Education
    • Night Owls
    • History and Philosophy of Music Education
    • Wind Repertory
  • Independent Study
    • Community Band Research Project
    • Graduate Student Journal
  • Diagnostic Exam Make Up Assignments
    • Form and Analsis
    • Counterpoint
    • History
  • Study for Preliminary Exams
  • Pre Dissertation Work
    • IRB Protocol
    • First Three Chapters
      • Introduction
      • Review of Literature
      • Methodology
  • Repair Workshop
  • Paper for Publication
  • Supervise a Student Teacher

Yikes!


The History and Philosophy of Music Education is an online class.  I swore I would never take another online class after my master's degree.  But, Dr. C. strongly recommended I take this one, so here I am.  This class is a little different than my master's degree.  It is a synchronous class, meaning that we all log in at the same time and are able to interact with one another.  That being said, the technology is still a bit clunky and it slows the pace of the class.  I admit to being less than engaged during the class period.  I am trying to stay positive, but I think I am going to have to suffer through this one.

Good news!  My sessions got accepted for the Connecticut Music Educators Association Conference.  So I will be speaking there at the end of April.


And now for the main event: the poster session at the Indiana Music Educators Association Conference.

In Preparation
For the poster session, we were instructed to have 30 copies of our abstract for interested parties to take with them.  I decided to do a nice, color layout because I get free color printing at school.
Doesn't that look nice?  Well, I waited until Wednesday to print it out (I left Thursday morning) and the printer at school was churning things out with yellow splotches all over them.  So, I went down to the library to do the printing.  But, they wanted 50 cents per page!  So, I went to Staples to print them.  They wanted 54 cents per page!  So, I decided to print them at home.  But, when I got home, I realized that my color ink cartridge was out of ink.  At this point, it was 8:45 pm.  I had just enough time to make it to Target before they closed.  I made it before closing, only to find out that Target doesn't carry that ink!  I ended up having to pack my printer, stop at Staples on my way to Indiana, and print my abstract at the hotel.  It ended up turning out fine.  Lesson learned: don't wait till the last minute.

The other thing I had to do when I got to the hotel was iron my suit.  I kept telling myself along the drive, "don't forget to iron your suit."  So, when I got to the hotel, I started printing the abstracts and then went to iron my suit.  Problem: I left me suit back in Philadelphia.  I had 30 minutes before stores closed to go buy a suit.  Luckily, there was a JCPenny right up the street and I was able to buy a suit before the store closed.  Lesson learned: make a packing list.

The Poster Session
I felt well-prepared for the poster session.  Dr. C. had given a very detailed account of what the Pennsylvania poster session is like: 100s of researchers, with their posters on the wall around a large room, talking to people in a packed room about their research.  When we were designing our posters in Research class last semester, Dr. C. made sure to tell us that these are professional posters, not the kind you put together with glue sticks and glitter.  This is what I was prepared for; this is not what I encountered.  When I arrived at the conference I was directed to the poster area.  It did not have its own room.  Rather, it was in the exhibition hall... in the back of the exhibition hall... in the back corner of the exhibition hall.  I felt like I was being punished for something.  When I got back to the poster area, I did not find 100s of posters. There were only 7 of us, though when I set up there were only 3 posters up already.  The first thing I noticed was that there was no wall.  They had set up tables for free-standing posters.  Nothing in the information told me that the poster needed to be free-standing.  Thankfully, this was the midwest where people are nice.  One of the facilities workers got me an easel and some cardboard so I could display my poster.

Once I had my poster set up, I examined the others already displayed.  The first one was nicely done.  The other two, both from the same university, looked like something out of a middle school science fair.  They consisted of sheets of computer paper, attached to tri-fold science fair displays with what I am assuming was glue stick.  Yikes!

The people on either side of me showed up later.  The guy to my left arrived assuming he would hang his poster on a wall as well.  I am glad I wasn't the only one!  It turns out, his research was on the same topic as mine.  Initially, I was disappointed.  I thought his research might make mine unnecessary.  But, as we talked I learned that we were investigating the problem from different angles.  He was looking at the ensemble outcomes and I was looking at the individual outcomes.  I think there might be some future collaboration for us.

It turns out that I knew the person to my right.  She worked with me in PG County for a couple years before going to get her Ph.D.  She teaches now at a small college in Indiana.  After catching up for a while, she invited me to come to her school to do a day of lectures and presentations, and conduct her band.  Score!

The Crowd
We were instructed to be at our posters to talk to the people for 30 minutes in the morning and 30 minutes in the afternoon.  Take a guess how many people came to talk about the posters in the morning?

What did you guess?  Was it 1 or more?  Then, you are wrong.  Not a single person come by to talk to us.  The afternoon was only marginally better.  There were two people that stopped by the poster.  One was a doctoral student from Indiana University and the other was a professor from Vandercook.  Both were good conversations, but I wanted to talk to more people!

Conclusions
The poster session, itself was underwhelming to say the least.  But, I did learn that I enjoy going to conferences on my own.  It forces me to meet and talk to new people.  I did some pretty solid networking while I was there.  In addition to the two people I already mentioned, I met a professor from Indiana University who gave a session on cognition.  We spoke about the overlaps between her presentation and the reading I have been doing on creative cognition.  We decided to trade reference lists and speak again after reading some new things.  I also met a professor (I forget which school he is from) who is interested in participating in my community band study.  So, it was a productive trip, just not in the way I thought it would be.

Well, that is it for now.  Try to stay warm out there this week!

Future Dr. Mitch, out!

Monday, January 11, 2016

Here we go again! Season 4, Episode 1

So, I know I said there would be more installments of the end of semester wrap up.  But, I made a new friend over break which kept me from being as productive as I should have been.  Let me introduce you to him.



http://www.foodqualitynews.com/var/plain_site/storage/images/publications/food-beverage-nutrition/foodqualitynews.com/food-alerts/salmonella-outbreak-in-wales-sickens-22/8364220-1-eng-GB/Salmonella-outbreak-in-Wales-sickens-22.jpg

Everyone, meet salmonella; salmonella meet everyone.  Yes, that's right, folks.  I was down with a pretty bad case of food poisoning over break.  As best I can determine, I got it from my obligatory Jewish dining experience of eating Chinese food on Christmas.  I wonder, does this count as a hate crime?

Anyway, let me catch you up on winter break.  First, here are the numbers from last semester:


Yes, that is an A- in Seminar.  That is a whole story unto itself, which I don't have time to dive into at this point.

So, over break, I applied to present at a few conferences.  I sent in my application to present at the fall NAfME conference.  I had such an incredible learning experience presenting at that conference this past fall; I am so hopeful that I will be able to present at this conference again.  I was accepted to present my research poster, "What about the 2nd Violins," at the Indiana Music Educators Association conference poster session.  That is happening this Friday, so you will get a full report next week on how that went.  I also have two pending session proposals for the Connecticut Music Educators Association conference.  We were supposed to hear back about that conference last month, but I got an email from them last week assuring me that they had just fallen behind and acceptances would be sent out soon.  So, lets keep our fingers crossed for that one!  Dr. C. had submitted a proposal for us to present at the spring NAfME conference, but I found out today that it was not accepted.  We are going to try to resubmit that one for another conference.  So, in short, there are tons of conferences in my future, it seems!

This semester is going to be an interesting one.  I am taking:
  • Graduate Seminar in Music Education
  • Night Owls
  • Wind Symphony
  • The History and Philosophy of Music Education
  • Wind Repertory
  • Supervised University Music Teaching
  • Independent Study
  • Preliminary Exam Prep
I am trying to transfer my Villanova summer music ed credits into Temple.  If they are accepted, this will be my final semester of classes.  That means that I could potentially be starting my dissertation in the fall, which means I have a lot to do in preparation this semester.  I have to write my IRB proposal and get started on the first three chapters of the dissertation, as well as studying for and passing the preliminary exam.  Yikes!

In other exciting news, I have officially gotten my first university job.  I am an instructor at a Pennsylvania university, where I will be supervising student teachers.  This semester, I only have one student teacher to supervise, but I imagine there will be others in the future.

In a deliberate effort to ensure I keep up with this blog, I have scheduled time every Monday to write my weekly entries.  So, you can look forward to regular posts again.

Until next week, Future Dr. Mitch, out!